What’s the Difference Between FTP, FTPS, and SFTP

When it comes to editing or developing a website, web app, or software in general, knowing how to use and using secure and efficient file transfer protocols is crucial. Understanding the differences between FTP (File Transfer Protocol), FTPS (File Transfer Protocol Secure), and SFTP (Secure File Transfer Protocol) can have an impact on your decision-making as it affects the security, reliability, and efficiency of file transfers. This comprehensive guide will help you understand these protocols, highlight their differences, and explain why hosting with Earth Girl Hosting is a secure and reliable choice for your hosting needs.

 

Throughout this article, command (control) and data channels will be mentioned. Here's what each one does:

Command Channel: The command channel, also known as control channel, is primarily used for exchanging commands between the client and server, such as login instructions (USER, PASS) and session controls. This channel typically operates over port 21 on the server side and remains open until the client sends a QUIT command or the server disconnects due to inactivity. The command channel ensures that the client and server can communicate and manage the session.

Data Channel: The data channel is solely responsible for transmitting data, including file transfers and directory listings. In active mode FTP, this channel generally uses port 20 on the server side. In passive mode, a randomized port is selected for the data transfer. Typical commands used in the data channel include LIST for directory listings, STOR for uploading files, and RETR for downloading files. Unlike the command channel, the data channel opens and closes with each transfer, establishing a new connection for every data exchange. This mechanism allows for efficient and controlled data transmission while keeping the command channel separate for session management.

 

What is FTP?

FTP (File Transfer Protocol) is a widely recognized network protocol that facilitates the transfer of files between hosts over a TCP-based network, such as the Internet. Developed in the early 1970s, FTP was one of the first methods for transferring files online and remains widely used due to its simplicity and speed.

Key Characteristics of FTP:

  • Simplicity and Speed: FTP is relatively simple to set up and use. It doesn't require much configuration, so it is accessible for users of all technical levels. Additionally, FTP's lack of encryption translates to a faster transfer speed because there's no need to process encryption and decryption.
  • Plain Text Transfers: A significant downside of FTP is that it transfers data in plain text. This means that user credentials and the files themselves are sent over the network without any encryption, making them vulnerable to interception by malicious actors.
  • Separate Control and Data Channels: FTP uses two distinct channels. The control channel manages commands and responses, while the data channel is dedicated to transferring the actual files. This dual-channel method helps optimize file transfers but can introduce complications with firewalls.
  • Active and Passive Modes: FTP can operate in either active or passive mode. Active mode requires the client to open a port, which can often be blocked by firewalls, while passive mode, initiated by the server, is more firewall-friendly but can be slower.

 

What is FTPS?

FTPS (FTP Secure) is another method used for secure file transfers. It adds a layer of security to the standard FTP protocol by enabling SSL/TLS (Secure Sockets Layer/Transport Layer Security) encryption. This method ensures that both commands and data are encrypted, protecting sensitive information during transfer.

Key Characteristics of FTPS:

  • Security: Unlike FTP, FTPS uses SSL/TLS encryption to safeguard data, providing a secure channel for transferring sensitive information. It is similar to SFTP.
  • Port Usage: FTPS typically operates using port 21 for control commands and a range of ports (990, 989, and others) for data transfer, which can complicate firewall configurations. However, it offers flexibility with two main modes: implicit and explicit.

Implicit vs. Explicit FTPS:

  • Implicit FTPS: In this stricter mode, the client connects to a specific port (usually port 990) where SSL/TLS is immediately invoked. All data, including commands, is encrypted from the outset, ensuring enhanced security right from the connection's initiation. This mode is less common and requires predefined connection parameters.
  • Explicit FTPS (FTPES): This mode is known as FTPES and starts with a standard FTP connection (usually on port 21) and then upgrades to a secured connection through explicit commands (e.g., AUTH TLS). This method is a bit less secure but is more flexible and is the preferred choice for compatibility with existing FTP infrastructure, allowing selective encryption of data channels.

 

What is SFTP?

SFTP (Secure File Transfer Protocol) is an extension of the Secure Shell (SSH) protocol to ensure secure file transfers. Unlike FTP, SFTP encrypts both commands and data, making the transmission secure from potential eavesdroppers.

Key Characteristics of SFTP:

  • Security: SFTP encrypts the data being transferred, which safeguards it from interception and unauthorized access. This makes SFTP a preferred choice for transferring sensitive information.
  • Different Port Usage: SFTP can be used with port 22 and also configured to be used with other ports, making it easier to manage within firewalls and simplifying the overall configuration.
  • Reliability and Efficiency: SFTP includes features such as resuming interrupted transfers, file integrity checks, and support for many file operations. This makes SFTP more reliable and efficient, especially for larger files or volumes of data.
  • SSH-Based: SFTP is part of the SSH protocol suite, providing all the benefits of SSH, including strong authentication and comprehensive security features.

 

Quick summary of FTP, FTPS, SFTP

Feature FTP FTPS (Explicit and Implicit) SFTP
Security Transmits data in plain text, prone to interception Uses SSL/TLS encryption, securing both commands and data Encrypts both commands and data, ensuring security
Performance Faster due to lack of encryption Slightly slower due to encryption overhead but largely dependent on network and server configurations May be slightly slower due to encryption overhead but offers greater security
Usability User-friendly, especially for beginners; many clients available Easy transition from FTP; most clients support FTPS with minimal additional configuration requirements Requires initial configuration; modern clients offer user-friendly interfaces
Firewall Compatibility Can be complicated due to dual-channel nature More complex due to dynamic port range (explicit) and simplified using port 990 (implicit) Simplified by using a single port
Port Usage Uses port 21 and a separate port for data FTPES uses port 21 (control) and a range of ports for data; Implicit FTPS uses ports 990 (control) & 989 (data) Primarily uses port 22

 

Detailed comparison: FTP vs FTPS vs SFTP

Security

FTP: One of the biggest drawbacks of FTP is its lack of security. Since it transmits data in plain text and uses two separate channels, it is highly susceptible to interception and attacks. An attacker can easily capture data packets and extract sensitive information, such as usernames and passwords.

FTPS: Similar to SFTP, FTPS ensures security by using SSL/TLS encryption to protect both commands and data. This added layer of encryption mitigates the vulnerabilities associated with plain text transfers in FTP, making it a secure alternative for sensitive data transfer.

SFTP: On the other hand, SFTP provides robust security through encryption. Both data and commands are encrypted, making it nearly impossible for attackers to intercept and read the transferred information. With SFTP, sensitive data like login credentials are safe from prying eyes.

Performance

FTP: Due to the absence of encryption, FTP generally offers faster transfer speeds. However, this speed comes at the cost of security. For applications where speed is critical and security is less of a concern, FTP might be considered a viable option.

FTPS: FTPS typically offers comparable performance to FTP since it can leverage existing FTP infrastructures. The encryption overhead can introduce slight delays, but these are generally minimal and acceptable for the added security.

SFTP: While SFTP may be slightly slower due to the overhead of encryption, it provides a much more secure environment. The performance difference is often negligible and well worth the trade-off for the added security, especially when transferring sensitive information.

Usability

FTP: FTP’s straightforward nature makes it user-friendly, especially for those new to file transfers. Numerous FTP clients, such as FileZilla, offer intuitive interfaces that simplify the file transfer process.

FTPS: FTPS can be user-friendly due to its similarities with standard FTP. It is easy to implement. Many FTP clients support FTPS with minimal additional configuration, making the transition to a secure protocol relatively straightforward for users familiar with FTP.

SFTP: While SFTP might require a bit more initial configuration, it’s generally quite user-friendly. Many modern SFTP clients like WinSCP also have friendly interfaces, and the protocol’s reliability features can make the overall transfer experience smoother. Side note: WinSCP even integrates PuTTY, an SSH client to manage servers via command-line interface.

Firewall Compatibility

FTP: FTP can be tricky to configure with firewalls due to its dual-channel system. Active mode, in particular, requires the client to open ports, which can be blocked by firewalls, causing connectivity issues.

FTPS: FTPES is firewall-friendly but can get more complex to configure due to its use of dynamic port ranges for data channels and port 21 for control commands. It does offer flexibility, though, since it allows both encrypted and unencrypted connections, but that requires more careful monitoring and configuration. However, implicit FTPS can simplify firewall configurations by using fewer ports. This approach simplifies firewall management because it adheres to a more predictable port usage, although it sacrifices some flexibility compared to FTPES. Implicit FTPS plays a "set it and forget it" role while FTEPS may require more monitoring due to open ports.

SFTP: Using a single port, typically port 22, SFTP simplifies firewall configurations. This makes SFTP more reliable and easier to work with in environments with strict firewall rules.

Port Usage

FTP: Uses port 21 for control commands and a separate port for data transfers, commonly port 20. This dual-channel approach impacts firewall configuration, making it more complex to manage—especially in secure environments with strict firewall policies.

FTPS: Uses port 21 for explicit mode and ports 990 and 989 for implicit mode. FTPES necessitates a more nuanced firewall configuration to ensure secure transfer. Implicit FTPS simplifies this and makes firewall management easier but less flexible.

SFTP: Primarily uses port 22 for all communications, significantly simplifying firewall configurations. By operating over a single port, SFTP minimizes the need for extensive firewall rules. Other ports, such as, 1840, 22500, and many others, can also be used for more security, preventing brute force attempts.

 

Real-life application of FTP, FTPS, and SFTP

FTP: Typically used by web developers to upload files to a web server, FTP facilitates the transfer of large amounts of data, such as website files, from local computers to hosting servers. However, because it lacks encryption, it's often used in environments where security isn't a primary concern.

FTPS: Used by organizations that require compliance with strict regulatory standards for data transfer, such as those in finance and e-commerce. FTPS provides enhanced security with SSL/TLS encryption while leveraging the existing FTP infrastructure. It requires careful firewall configuration to manage security effectively. It can be used by webmasters and web developers to securely transfer files to build websites for their customers.

SFTP: Commonly used in industries like finance and healthcare, SFTP ensures secure file transfers by encrypting data in transit. This makes it ideal for transferring sensitive information, such as financial records or patient data, between institutions over the Internet. Along with SSH, it's heavily used by hosting companies to securely transfer their client's website files and manage server data, ensuring encrypted connections.

 

Which should you use?

In short:

  • Avoid FTP unless absolutely necessary due to legacy constraints.
  • Consider FTPS if SFTP is not an option and some level of security is required.
  • Choose SFTP for the best security and ease of use with firewalls.

Basically, the choice between FTP, SFTP, and FTPS depends on your specific needs and priorities. Here are some scenarios to consider:

  • If Security is a Priority: If you are transferring sensitive or confidential data, SFTP or FTPS are the clear choices. Both use encryption to safeguard your information from unauthorized access.
  • For Speed and Simplicity: If you need quick and easy transfers for non-sensitive data, FTP might be sufficient. Just be aware of its security limitations.
  • Combining Both: Some users might opt to use multiple protocols, using FTP for non-sensitive tasks and SFTP or FTPS for secure file transfers.

 

Why choose Earth Girl Hosting?

Choosing the right hosting provider significantly impacts your website’s performance and security. Earth Girl Hosting offers several compelling reasons to make it your go-to provider:

Robust Security with FTPS and SFTP

Earth Girl Hosting ensures that your data remains secure by supporting FTPS and SFTP (and SSH on demand) for all file transfers. This means that every time you upload or download files, your information is encrypted and protected from unauthorized access, providing you with peace of mind. Earth Girl Hosting uses 2 different firewalls along with SFTP and a custom port to manage client files. We also regularly change that port to prevent hack attempts.

Eco-Friendly Practices

Earth Girl Hosting is committed to eco-friendly and sustainable practices. We use renewable energy sources, where available, to power data centers, making us an excellent choice for environmentally conscious users. By hosting with Earth Girl Hosting, you're contributing to a greener earth without compromising on performance or security.

Reliable Customer Support

In the realm of web hosting, reliable customer support is invaluable. Earth Girl Hosting prides itself on offering top-notch 24/7/365 customer service, with a dedicated team based in North America that is ready to assist you with any issues you might encounter. Whether it's helping with file transfers or addressing technical inquiries, our support team is readily available via phone and ticket to ensure your experience is smooth and hassle-free.

Comprehensive Hosting Features

Earth Girl Hosting provides a wide range of hosting features to meet diverse needs, offering scalable solutions that grow with your business. Our plans include ample storage, bandwidth, free SSL certificates, cPanel, Softaculous for one-click CMS installation, and advanced tools, making it easy to manage your website efficiently.

 

Conclusion

It's essential to understand the differences between FTP, SFTP, and FTPS to choose the right file transfer protocol for your needs.

While FTP might offer simplicity and speed, SFTP and FTPS provide robust security features, making them the better choices for most scenarios. With Earth Girl Hosting, you get the best of all worlds: secure, sustainable, and user-friendly hosting solutions that includes access to FTP, SFTP, and FTPS.

When you choose Earth Girl Hosting, you're not only opting for a hosting provider that values honesty, security, and performance but also one that prioritizes environmental sustainability. Whether you're a small business owner, a startup, a nonprofit, a developer, or a blogger, Earth Girl Hosting has the right plan for you.

By ensuring that your files are transferred securely with SFTP or FTPS, you protect your data and maintain the integrity of your website. Stay ahead of potential threats by choosing the right protocol and a hosting provider that aligns with your values. Experience the benefits of secure file transfers and sustainable hosting with Earth Girl Hosting today.

 

Image by storyset on Freepik

About Earth Girl Hosting

Earth Girl Hosting offers web hosting for any type of website, including WordPress, OpenCart, Joomla!, Drupal, and more. Free SSL, free daily backups, 24/7/365 North American support by phone & ticket.

Leave a Comment





This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.